Ken Field’s ‘Cartography.’ [note the full stop] has now been published and copies are winging their way out to early purchasers. But, what is it really like, and is it worth the hefty price tag?
Disclosure: I made a small contribution [of a double page spread] and also was one of a small group of people who were asked to review a working copy of the book in its early developmental stages …… and I am a friend of Ken.
I always take the request to be a critical friend of someone’s work very seriously and duly I set about making notes, with suggestions for clarification and emphasis to (hopefully) enhance some of its 500+ pages. This produced a 1,000 Word file which went back to the author for consideration. One example will suffice to show the detail. There is a page on ‘map traps’ – deliberate errors included to try to catch copyright infringement. I suggested: Map traps – maybe an aside in this page about cartographers ‘signatures’ in maps. See page 105/6 in Mike Parker’s ‘Map Addict’ on OS names of surveyor in cliff drawings on IoW.
I hope the critiquing was useful, though I’ve not been back to see if any suggestions were taken up.
The most impressive thing about the book is the radical approach taken. Ken explains its different take on structuring the information on the mapping process. This is not likely to be a book that is read in a traditional way. Folk are likely (positively encouraged) to dip in and out, the layout has linked navigation aids. There is a colour-coded thematic index, and an alphabetical index, together with multiple ‘see also’ links on each double page spread.
What else is in there? A neat idea is the inclusion of 25 ‘guest spreads’, where emminent cartographers were asked to provide examples of maps that interest them, with short explanations of why. Seeing the names of Waldo Tobler, Mark Monmonier, Danny Dorling and Menno-Jan Kraak alongside my own gives me a quiet sense of pride. My contribution is a map of ‘Airspace: The Invisible Infrastructure’ commisioned by the National Air Traffic Services (NATS), which coincidentally one of my sons has just finished training with.
NB: It is a still from a video, so for best effect check the video it comes from: https://vimeo.com/110348926
One other thing that really pleased me was to see that Roger Anson had been asked to write the Foreword. He was the Senior Lecturer who ran the cartography course at Oxford Polytechnic/University who inspired me in my career, and obviously did for Ken too.
See what do I think of the book?
First off, may I say that I am very impressed overall with the book. I like the concept and the delivery.
These were the first two sentences of my feedback when critiquing the early version of it. When I saw a further iteration I pronounced it a ‘game-changer’, and I really think it is the best text on cartography in recent years.
But don’t just take my word for it . When writing about the book in the Bulletin of the Society of Cartographers, Chris Wesson concluded his detailed review:
What Kenneth Field has created here is a brilliant reference book on behalf of our field of cartography. Finally! A book that truly represents Cartography in 2018.
See his full review, which is thorough and considered, at this link [PDF].
Finally, is it worth the cover price, which is admittedly on the high side. I feel that it is, given the breadth of coverage and particularly the most excellent illustrations, many of which have been created especially for this volume. Buy it if you can afford it.
PRO TIP: and if you CAN’T afford it, then sign up for the next Esri Cartography MOOC, which I can guarantee will include loads of stuff from the book, as it is run by Ken, plus his colleagues at Esri who worked on putting the book together.
I have said elsewhere (when writing about the Golden Stag Mile) that events like the Night of the 10,000 PBs at Parliament Hill have shown that concentrated single event evenings are great fun, AND produce great results for the competitors as they are graded races. The success of Highgate Harriers’ Ben Pochee at organising the 10,000m event has caused a brilliant ripple effect, and other such events are following on from this great work, and coming soon is what promises to be a great event for the 5000m.
The details of the inaugural ‘MK5000 PB Special in association with the BMC’ on Saturday 11 August show how clubs like Marshall Milton Keynes AC are gearing these events up to meet the athlete’s needs, and very much putting them first:
- a day/evening of high quality 5000m races at the track in Milton Keynes. ‘A’ races are BMC Gold Standard; races leading up to that will be graded based on PBs.
- put on by club runners for club runners; everything will be geared towards helping fellow athletes run as fast as possible.
- on track support, a food and drinks festival as well as music to help inspire you.
Only 500 places are available, so enter as soon as you can.
BMC Gold Standard entry (14.40 for men / 17.35 for women):
UKA club entry (Currently 17.59 for men/ 20.59 for women:
One of the organising team, Elliot Hind, commented:
It’s great the BMC were so keen to be involved and we are able to take a step forwards giving club athletes the platform to really push themselves.
He also confirmed that, ‘we will be providing pacers, taking official results at 3000m, and have got clocks every 200m and are looking to get predicted finish times on the screens too’.
SO, if you are looking for a 5000m PB, want to try a track 5k for the first time, or just want to watch athletics close up (for free), MK14 6DT is the place to be on Saturday 11 August 2018.
Joss Naylor was on great form at the Buxton Adventure Festival gig at the Buxton Opera House (on 19 June 2018), as we shared stories of his life and times.
I arrived early to book into the marvellous Old Hall Hotel, have a bite to eat, scope out the Opera House and meet BAF organiser Matt Heason and Joss to setup the visuals, do a soundcheck, and check how the timings of our parts of the event.
It was a lovely sunny evening and it was great to see the SOLD OUT sign on the doors as they set up an outdoor bar for the audience who were starting to congregate on the space outside of the theatre. Six hundred was apparently the auditorium size.
After an intro from Matt, and a few words on The Brathay Trust, which it was Joss’s wish that all the profits should go to, I took the stage before possibly the largest crowd I had given a talk to. I ran through my presentation on The Bob Graham Round, its history and heroes, interspersed with stories and photos/videos from my friend Neil Walker’s recent BGR. We then had a short break for drinks, and for a chance to sell and sign a few books.
The audience were perhaps surprised when Joss chose to give them what he called a ‘little lecture’ to start the second half. His theme was badgers and foxes and how we mistreat the animal kingdom, with specific examples local to him.
I then sat down with Joss and fed him some questions, which I hoped would bring some good stories out from him, and later took questions from the audience. This produced some fascinating responses from Joss, only some of which I can remember.
Some examples will have to suffice to show the range of topics, and highlight Joss’s humorous and informative replies.
On being asked from the floor what the Queen said to him when he was presented with his MBE (for his charity work) he replied without blinking: “You are a good looking boy!”.
When I asked him why he hadn’t beaten the UK 24 hour track record when he attempted it he replied it was the physiotherapist’s fault. I think I heard him correctly, as he said ‘he was massaging his leg and stuffed it up my arse’. He had been tracking at 2-38 marathon pace before that happened and reckoned he would have smashed the record without that painful intervention.
After dissing those that planned endurance challenges ‘on a computer’, he revealed that when he did his Lakes 72 peaks extended BG record in 24 hrs in 1975 he ‘ran out of peaks’. (This was subsequently raised to 77 by Mark Hartell, quite possibly with the aid of computer planning!).
I thought I knew Joss pretty well, but he surprised me when he said at one point that he had done 30 mins for a 10k road race once. His witty put-down of slow latter day fell ‘runners’ who chatted all round the course was based on how long he had to stand around in wet and cold conditions marshalling them in races.
He replied to the question: How would you like to be remembered? – “As a man who enjoyed life”.
He gave his thoughts on nutrition and hydration (salt water apparently being his secret), and training, and described some of his many race successes but also was not afraid to mention the less successful days out. He closed with the advice: “Be nice to each other”.
We then repaired to the foyer where Joss patiently signed absolutely loads of books and autographs, speaking with and posing for photos for everyone. The photo shows the queue going out of the foyer entrance as people waited patiently for their turn.
A fabulous evening. What a legend he is and a fabulous human being too.
For more information on my book ‘The Round: in Bob Graham’s footsteps’ (and my other 2 books), see my page at Sandstone Press.
The image is part of the cover quote for ‘The Round’ from Joss Naylor.
Really looking forward to sharing a stage with Joss Naylor next week (Tues 19th) at the Buxton Adventure Festival. I will be talking about The Bob Graham Round – ‘an exploration of the what, why and how of this classic fell endurance challenge’. I will then introduce and interview Joss and encourage him (as if he’ll need encouraging!) to talk about his life of running and farming, before taking questions from the audience.
Having interviewed him a couple of times for my books (available on the night), I know him to be riveting to listen to, as he recalls some of his amazing exploits on the fells. Co-founder of the London Marathon, Chris Brasher, described Joss Naylor as ‘The Greatest of Them All’, a title he bestowed on Joss when he ran 72 Lake District mountains in 24 hours.
It may be possible to snap up the last few tickets for the gig at:
All proceeds from Joss’s talk will be donated to the Brathay Trust. They work with children, young people and families to help them fulfil their potential and make positive choices, working with them in their own communities and at their residential centres in the Lake District.
The Golden Stag Mile is back at Finsbury Park
on Friday 6 July 2018. Re-arranged for Fri 20 July 2018 [entries still available], because of a:
clash with the huge Wireless Festival in the park, a potential England WC Quarter Final (jinx), and electonic timing being no longer available on the 6 July date
Come and try the greatest track distance, the mile. Events like the Night of the 10,000 PBs at Parliament Hill have shown that concentrated single event evenings are great fun, AND produce great results for the competitors as they are graded races.
The Golden Stag Mile is open to all clubs/individuals, but entries are filling fast. Entries: https://www.entrycentral.com/goldenstagmile
Now in its fifth year, The Golden Stag Mile will always be for athletes of all abilities, from ten minutes or more to four minutes or less. The races are graded so that you get to race people of a similar ability as we love a close finish! Previous editions have seen British, European, and even World age group records, with a large crowd cheering our athletes on from lane three of the track.
The races start at 18:45 and the pace of each race goes up as the sun comes down. At the end of the night the final races will decide the Golden Stag Mile titles for 2018. We hope you will come for the whole evening to cheer on all of our milers.
Entries for the Golden Stag Mile will remain open until 30 June, or until the races are full. Races will be seeded based on your predicted time. The time you put will determine which race you go in, so please be realistic. You can change your predicted time as many times as you like, but no changes will be accepted after 30 June.
New for 2018 – Our final two races will be for elite men and elite women. We are pleased to offer the following prize structure for these races:
1st – £100 cash, 2nd – £50 cash, 3rd – £25 cash
Link for full results for the 2014-2017 races.